Gardner Trial to Start Tuesday

Opening arguments will be heard Tuesday morning in Arlington Circuit Court in the trial of Falls Church resident Michael Gardner on four felony charges of aggravated sexual battery and animate object sexual penetration involving three young girls.

In her presentations to the juror pool, prosecuting attorney Nicole Wittmann mentioned that her list of 13 witnesses scheduled to testify at the trial includes the three girls allegedly attacked, along with the mother of one and the fathers of two others. The 23 defense witnesses announced by one of Gardner’s lawyers, Jonathan Shapiro, include Gardner’s wife, Falls Church City Council member Robin Gardner, along with their son and daughter, who are twins. Shapiro told prospective jurors that he has not yet decided whether Gardner will take the stand in his own defense, and cautioned them not to assume anything untoward if Gardner ultimately does not testify.

Five rounds of jury selection Monday yielded 26 prospective jurors, a number that will be whittled down to 14 (including two alternates) first thing Tuesday morning before the panel is sworn in. Both the prosecution and defense estimated that the trial will run through Friday or next Monday before being handed to the jury.

Judge Benjamin Kendrick rejected a defense motion Monday morning to hold two separate trials due to the alleged acts having been committed on separate occasions last June. Kendrick also said he would wait “until the appropriate time” in the trial to rule on a defense motion to transport the jury to Gardner’s home to view the bedroom and basement in which the alleged attacks occurred.

Three women among the 10 prospective jurors in the day’s final pool were dismissed after indicating that they found the charges disturbing. Two of the three are elementary-school teachers. In an earlier pool, a grandmother of two girls stated that as a juror, “I would not presume Mr. Gardner guilty, but I would certainly be thinking about my little granddaughters. … I would hope I could be impartial, but the allegations are upsetting.” She was dismissed, together with another woman who concurred with the comments.

Family members of the alleged victims and friends of the defendant attended Monday’s proceedings.

Recent News

New Wave of West Falls Retailers, Homes Announced

New Wave of West Falls Retailers, Homes Announced

As Falls Church’s stunning new 10-acre development speeds toward construction completion, new retailers and housing options are opening up with…
Tough F.C. Town Hall On Budget Tonight

Tough F.C. Town Hall On Budget Tonight

Doing with $1.2 million less cannot come easily for anyone, except perhaps for its anyone in the nation’s wealthiest top…
Beyer: “Hegseth Must Resign or Be Fired”

Beyer: “Hegseth Must Resign or Be Fired”

April 21, 2025 (Washington, D.C.) – U.S. Representative Don Beyer (D-VA), who represents a Northern Virginia district in the U.S. House…
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
On Key

Stories that may interest you

Tough F.C. Town Hall On Budget Tonight

Doing with $1.2 million less cannot come easily for anyone, except perhaps for its anyone in the nation’s wealthiest top 1 percent. Thus, the public town hall tonight (Thursday, April

Beyer: “Hegseth Must Resign or Be Fired”

April 21, 2025 (Washington, D.C.) – U.S. Representative Don Beyer (D-VA), who represents a Northern Virginia district in the U.S. House that includes the Pentagon, again called for the resignation or termination of

Support Local News!

For Information on Advertising:

Legitimate news organizations need grass roots support like never before, and that includes your Falls Church News-Press. For more than 33 years, your News-Press has kept its readers informed and enlightened. We can’t continue without the support of our readers. This means YOU! Please step up in these challenging times to support the news source you are reading right now!