
The great Arlington fracas over pipestem lots was settled calmly this month. It was a rare Kumbaya moment in which county officials, a developer and neighboring homeowners each gave an inch.
The passions arose last fall over plans by the builder of a nearly complete new home at 2615 N. Nottingham St., to take advantage of backyard open space and erect an additional grand-scale house accessible by the type of elongated driveway that gives pipestems (some 20 of which exist in Arlington) their name.
Neighbors throughout the affected civic association zone rose up on listserves and in testimony at hearings. They complained that the size of the crammed-in house would block views, destroy trees, increase traffic and endanger storm drainage. They argued that granting a use permit would set a precedent for reduced setbacks that would add to what is already a problem, in my humble opinion: Arlington’s vanishing side yards.
But Andrew Moore of Arlington Designer Homes wanted another of his signature 21st-century green homes. He gets to take advantage of 1969 zoning on Nottingham Street that was grandfathered in when Arlington banned new pipestem development in 2003.
Both sides hired attorneys.
Arlington has a history of grass-roots activism on the pipestem issue. Back in the late 1990s, my friends Mike and Mary Lou Higgs assembled blockmates on North 23rd Street and filed suit to prevent builders Michael and Delores Kirkbride from adding a home with an infill pipestem in the neighborhood “meadow.” It went all the way to the Virginia Supreme Court, which backed the Arlington Board of Zoning Appeals’ denial of a permit. (That meadow today is protected by an addition to the existing home where the pipestem driveway would have been.)
In 2005, the county imposed restrictions on lot coverage for new homes, to preserve some green space between structures. But that hasn’t arrested the movement toward taller, fatter suburban castles. The “monster house” on North Sycamore and 27th Street still towers over its neighbors’ bungalows, and anger at oversized dwellings is the cover story of the new issue of Arlington magazine.
But in the Nottingham Street case, the county board, after endless hours of emotional presentations, facilitated a summit and encouraged the parties to compromise. On Feb. 11, it was announced opponents had done so.
The result: a shorter and narrower home, fewer windows, new trees, a fence and improved drainage, a green roof and a separate garage. “It’s a different architectural style than we had, but it’s going to be a great home for someone,” the builder told reporters.
“We are pleased that an agreement has been reached,” Karla Brown, president, Leeway Overlee Civic Association, told me. “Although the process of coming to a compromise was at times very difficult and contentious, the end product appears to be one that everyone can live with.”
Board members expressed relief and said the process worked as intended.
Yet future such disputes are likely. My friend Terry Showman, a homebuilder, has long opposed the county’s policy of requiring a use permit for what he believes should be an owner’s building privileges by right. He says there are many more pipestem lots and that opening too many such decisions up to citizens input wastes staff time and costs everybody money.
Such private decisions have sizable public impact. No Arlington home is an island.
Charlie Clark may be e-mailed at cclarkjedd@aol.com
Our Man in Arlington
FCNP.com
The great Arlington fracas over pipestem lots was settled calmly this month. It was a rare Kumbaya moment in which county officials, a developer and neighboring homeowners each gave an inch.
The passions arose last fall over plans by the builder of a nearly complete new home at 2615 N. Nottingham St., to take advantage of backyard open space and erect an additional grand-scale house accessible by the type of elongated driveway that gives pipestems (some 20 of which exist in Arlington) their name.
Neighbors throughout the affected civic association zone rose up on listserves and in testimony at hearings. They complained that the size of the crammed-in house would block views, destroy trees, increase traffic and endanger storm drainage. They argued that granting a use permit would set a precedent for reduced setbacks that would add to what is already a problem, in my humble opinion: Arlington’s vanishing side yards.
But Andrew Moore of Arlington Designer Homes wanted another of his signature 21st-century green homes. He gets to take advantage of 1969 zoning on Nottingham Street that was grandfathered in when Arlington banned new pipestem development in 2003.
Both sides hired attorneys.
Arlington has a history of grass-roots activism on the pipestem issue. Back in the late 1990s, my friends Mike and Mary Lou Higgs assembled blockmates on North 23rd Street and filed suit to prevent builders Michael and Delores Kirkbride from adding a home with an infill pipestem in the neighborhood “meadow.” It went all the way to the Virginia Supreme Court, which backed the Arlington Board of Zoning Appeals’ denial of a permit. (That meadow today is protected by an addition to the existing home where the pipestem driveway would have been.)
In 2005, the county imposed restrictions on lot coverage for new homes, to preserve some green space between structures. But that hasn’t arrested the movement toward taller, fatter suburban castles. The “monster house” on North Sycamore and 27th Street still towers over its neighbors’ bungalows, and anger at oversized dwellings is the cover story of the new issue of Arlington magazine.
But in the Nottingham Street case, the county board, after endless hours of emotional presentations, facilitated a summit and encouraged the parties to compromise. On Feb. 11, it was announced opponents had done so.
The result: a shorter and narrower home, fewer windows, new trees, a fence and improved drainage, a green roof and a separate garage. “It’s a different architectural style than we had, but it’s going to be a great home for someone,” the builder told reporters.
“We are pleased that an agreement has been reached,” Karla Brown, president, Leeway Overlee Civic Association, told me. “Although the process of coming to a compromise was at times very difficult and contentious, the end product appears to be one that everyone can live with.”
Board members expressed relief and said the process worked as intended.
Yet future such disputes are likely. My friend Terry Showman, a homebuilder, has long opposed the county’s policy of requiring a use permit for what he believes should be an owner’s building privileges by right. He says there are many more pipestem lots and that opening too many such decisions up to citizens input wastes staff time and costs everybody money.
Such private decisions have sizable public impact. No Arlington home is an island.
Charlie Clark may be e-mailed at cclarkjedd@aol.com
Recent News
Spanberger Pledges to Protect Virginians’ Fundamental Rights, Reproductive Freedoms
**DOWNLOADABLE VIDEO: Spanberger Urges Virginians to Vote to Protect Reproductive Rights This November** Spanberger: “My Opponent Has Made Clear That
CBC LWV How To Become a Candidate Forum
Running for office has always been a key facet of our democratic system of government but, in these fraught times,
Warner Unveils Latest Legislation in Push to Make Housing More Affordable for Virginians
WASHINGTON — U.S. Sen. Mark R. Warner (D-VA) has introduced two new pieces of bipartisan legislation to encourage new development, expand
Warner, Young, Colleagues Push Trump Administration to Fill Sudan Special Envoy Position as Civil War Continues
WASHINGTON – Today, U.S. Sens. Mark R. Warner (D-VA) and Todd Young (R-IN) wrote to Secretary of State Marco Rubio urging him to
Judge Giles Rejects Trump Administration Forum Shopping In Badar Khan Suri Case
Congressman Don Beyer (D-VA) today issued the following statement welcoming a ruling by Judge Patricia Tolliver Giles rejecting the Trump Administration’s attempts
Virginia Delegation Blasts Trump Administration’s Attacks On CDC Programs That Address America’s Maternal Health Crisis
Today, U.S. Senators Tim Kaine, a member of the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions (HELP) Committee, and Mark R.
Stories that may interest you
Spanberger Pledges to Protect Virginians’ Fundamental Rights, Reproductive Freedoms
**DOWNLOADABLE VIDEO: Spanberger Urges Virginians to Vote to Protect Reproductive Rights This November** Spanberger: “My Opponent Has Made Clear That She Would Put Further Restrictions On a Woman’s Access to
CBC LWV How To Become a Candidate Forum
Running for office has always been a key facet of our democratic system of government but, in these fraught times, it looms more important than ever. With this in mind
Warner Unveils Latest Legislation in Push to Make Housing More Affordable for Virginians
WASHINGTON — U.S. Sen. Mark R. Warner (D-VA) has introduced two new pieces of bipartisan legislation to encourage new development, expand supply, and make housing more affordable for Virginians. “In communities
Warner, Young, Colleagues Push Trump Administration to Fill Sudan Special Envoy Position as Civil War Continues
WASHINGTON – Today, U.S. Sens. Mark R. Warner (D-VA) and Todd Young (R-IN) wrote to Secretary of State Marco Rubio urging him to work with President Trump to appoint a new Special Envoy