
Ever so tentatively and haltingly, in the context of the recent near total meltdown of the global economy, the two most feared words in the western world have begun to enjoy what could become a revival.
Ever so tentatively and haltingly, in the context of the recent near total meltdown of the global economy, the two most feared words in the western world have begun to enjoy what could become a revival.
The words are not “liberal” or even “socialist,” but something far more scary: “Karl Marx.”
Many born since 1980, or especially since the fall of the Berlin Wall in 1988, may have hardly heard of him. Those who have may only recall a photo of a frumpy-looking man with a bushy beard, a “mug shot” that could easily be confused with that of Johannes Brahms, for example, and of the well-worn phrase, “failed theory.”
Otherwise, he’s remembered as the spiritual father of the western free markets’ greatest threats, the Soviet Union, Communist China and other statist regimes from North Korea to Cuba, and even Venezuela. As far removed as he, personally, was from the violent convulsions of the early 20th century that gave rise, in the wake of the Great War that made mincemeat of modern civilization, he and his “Communist Manifesto” of 1848 were on the flags waved in the midst of those revolutionary times.
Few bother these days to take a look at what Marx actually talked about in such dry and boring detail in his “Das Kapital,” or other more philosophical writings, about the economic and social alienation arising from the internal contradictions in the capitalist mode of production.
But a closer look reveals a poignant and almost uncanny critique of what’s unfolded in the last 30 years that triggered the 2008 economic meltdown, and the probable slow slide of the U.S. economy into a third Great Depression.
Creighton University Assistant Professor of Philosophy, Dr. Amy Wendling authored the book, “Karl Marx on Technology and Alienation, “in May 2009, based on a study of Marx’s unpublished notebooks from July 1852, and in the Summer 2010 edition of Creighton’s online magazine, she wrote “A Second Glance: The Karl Marx You Never Knew.”
There she cites the beginning evocations of Marx’s name in the midst of the current crisis coming from, of all people, Pope Benedict, in a 2007 encyclical Spe Salvi. While critical of Marxism, generally, it “praises Marx’s intentions and broad historical knowledge.”
In 2008, the German Archbishop Reinhard Marx (no relation) “nods to Karl Marx’s crisis theory, his critique of capitalism’s internal contradictions, as his diagnosis of widespread social alienation.” That, in turn, was cited in a recent article in Time Australia by Peter Gumbel.
Last fall, an article by Richard Owen in The Times Online cites philosopher George Sans’ renewed interest in Marx, as Sans published an article in a Jesuit journal and later in the Vatican newspaper, L’Osservatore Romano. Sans hailed Marx’s ideas about the widespread social alienation present in capitalist society.
Dr. Wendling explores Marx in three new ways in her book: Marx as Theorist of Economic Crisis, Marx as Technological Historian (partly due to his profession as a newspaper reporter), and Marx as Philosopher.
In my own view, Marx made two seminal points from which the rest of his theories and observations are derived.
First: Marx identified a critical distinction between capital that is invested in the generation of real, tangible wealth and capital invested in paper values and gratuitous discretionary consumerism. This is something that has always been violently opposed by the free market capitalist proponents who brought us the meltdown of 2008. Marx argued that with advances in technology, he could “imagine a world without food scarcity,” as Dr. Wendling notes.
Second: Marx launched a scathing critique of the philosophies of egoism, hedonism, structuralism, nihilism, anarchism and other variants of radical selfishness and individualism, when he took on a Max Stirner, a modern precursor of that regrettable socio-political trend, in in his “German Ideology.”
In the U.S., Marx’s influence strengthened opposition to child labor, and the fight of labor unions for livable wages and working conditions. Countering this, “free market” capitalists promoted radical individualist philosophies ranging from Ayn Rand to William Burroughs, tracing their legacies to Stirner and Nietzsche, as cheerleaders for much of the misery of the recent era that’s led to the recent collapse.
A Revival of Karl Marx?
Nicholas F. Benton
The words are not “liberal” or even “socialist,” but something far more scary: “Karl Marx.”
Many born since 1980, or especially since the fall of the Berlin Wall in 1988, may have hardly heard of him. Those who have may only recall a photo of a frumpy-looking man with a bushy beard, a “mug shot” that could easily be confused with that of Johannes Brahms, for example, and of the well-worn phrase, “failed theory.”
Otherwise, he’s remembered as the spiritual father of the western free markets’ greatest threats, the Soviet Union, Communist China and other statist regimes from North Korea to Cuba, and even Venezuela. As far removed as he, personally, was from the violent convulsions of the early 20th century that gave rise, in the wake of the Great War that made mincemeat of modern civilization, he and his “Communist Manifesto” of 1848 were on the flags waved in the midst of those revolutionary times.
Few bother these days to take a look at what Marx actually talked about in such dry and boring detail in his “Das Kapital,” or other more philosophical writings, about the economic and social alienation arising from the internal contradictions in the capitalist mode of production.
But a closer look reveals a poignant and almost uncanny critique of what’s unfolded in the last 30 years that triggered the 2008 economic meltdown, and the probable slow slide of the U.S. economy into a third Great Depression.
Creighton University Assistant Professor of Philosophy, Dr. Amy Wendling authored the book, “Karl Marx on Technology and Alienation, “in May 2009, based on a study of Marx’s unpublished notebooks from July 1852, and in the Summer 2010 edition of Creighton’s online magazine, she wrote “A Second Glance: The Karl Marx You Never Knew.”
There she cites the beginning evocations of Marx’s name in the midst of the current crisis coming from, of all people, Pope Benedict, in a 2007 encyclical Spe Salvi. While critical of Marxism, generally, it “praises Marx’s intentions and broad historical knowledge.”
In 2008, the German Archbishop Reinhard Marx (no relation) “nods to Karl Marx’s crisis theory, his critique of capitalism’s internal contradictions, as his diagnosis of widespread social alienation.” That, in turn, was cited in a recent article in Time Australia by Peter Gumbel.
Last fall, an article by Richard Owen in The Times Online cites philosopher George Sans’ renewed interest in Marx, as Sans published an article in a Jesuit journal and later in the Vatican newspaper, L’Osservatore Romano. Sans hailed Marx’s ideas about the widespread social alienation present in capitalist society.
Dr. Wendling explores Marx in three new ways in her book: Marx as Theorist of Economic Crisis, Marx as Technological Historian (partly due to his profession as a newspaper reporter), and Marx as Philosopher.
In my own view, Marx made two seminal points from which the rest of his theories and observations are derived.
First: Marx identified a critical distinction between capital that is invested in the generation of real, tangible wealth and capital invested in paper values and gratuitous discretionary consumerism. This is something that has always been violently opposed by the free market capitalist proponents who brought us the meltdown of 2008. Marx argued that with advances in technology, he could “imagine a world without food scarcity,” as Dr. Wendling notes.
Second: Marx launched a scathing critique of the philosophies of egoism, hedonism, structuralism, nihilism, anarchism and other variants of radical selfishness and individualism, when he took on a Max Stirner, a modern precursor of that regrettable socio-political trend, in in his “German Ideology.”
In the U.S., Marx’s influence strengthened opposition to child labor, and the fight of labor unions for livable wages and working conditions. Countering this, “free market” capitalists promoted radical individualist philosophies ranging from Ayn Rand to William Burroughs, tracing their legacies to Stirner and Nietzsche, as cheerleaders for much of the misery of the recent era that’s led to the recent collapse.
Nicholas Benton may be emailed at nfbenton@fcnp.com
Recent News
George Mason Hosts James Madison Saturday for In-State Clash, November 28, 2025
FAIRFAX, Va. — The George Mason University men’s basketball team (7-0) hosts the 102nd meeting between the Patriots and James
New F.C.-Based Paris Baguette To Open This Saturday, Nov. 29
Wednesday, Nov. 26 — This Saturday, Nov. 29, a new French-inspired bakery is opening in downtown Falls Church. In the
News Briefs 11-27-2025
Shields Vows No Action on Virginia Village Without Input At Monday’s Falls Church City Council meeting, City Manager Wyatt Shields
‘Rock of Ages’ Brought 80’s ‘Foreigner’ & ‘Journey’ Hits
Last weekend’s stunning performance of the hit musical “Rock of Ages” by the drama team at Meridian High School in
Our Man In Arlington 11-27-2025
Did you know that the first Thanksgiving celebration in America took place in Virginia? Well, as with many “firsts”, there
Mustangs Rock the Stage In Their Performance of ‘Rock of Ages’
by Daria Adler The Meridian High School theater department performed to a packed house last week with their latest musical,
Stories that may interest you
George Mason Hosts James Madison Saturday for In-State Clash, November 28, 2025
FAIRFAX, Va. — The George Mason University men’s basketball team (7-0) hosts the 102nd meeting between the Patriots and James Madison (5-3) on Saturday in Fairfax. Tip-off between the Patriots
New F.C.-Based Paris Baguette To Open This Saturday, Nov. 29
Wednesday, Nov. 26 — This Saturday, Nov. 29, a new French-inspired bakery is opening in downtown Falls Church. In the Hillwood Shopping Center, at its opposite end from the Aldi
News Briefs 11-27-2025
Shields Vows No Action on Virginia Village Without Input At Monday’s Falls Church City Council meeting, City Manager Wyatt Shields assured the Council that nothing of substance will happen in
‘Rock of Ages’ Brought 80’s ‘Foreigner’ & ‘Journey’ Hits
Last weekend’s stunning performance of the hit musical “Rock of Ages” by the drama team at Meridian High School in Falls Church revolved around two of the most iconic songs