On Monday, the Washington Post carried a provocative story about the perennial debate in the college and university community about the nature of an undergraduate curriculum.
In a nutshell, the debate is between the relative merits of a curriculum designed to provide high level skills in an increasingly professional job market as opposed a more general understanding of history and culture. As the headline put it, “Balancing Academic Tradition and Skills Employers Demand.”
I approach this debate from several perspectives: as a college student in the 1950’s, ‘60’s and now; as a college instructor in the 1960’s and now; and as a former member of George Mason University’s Board of Visitors.
My basic belief is that a college education should be principally designed to greatly expand students’ circles of knowledge; to introduce students to intellectual concepts, culture, literature, music, economic theories, theoretical mathematics and languages; and to give them the ability to articulate the knowledge they have gained. In the vernacular, it is called readin’, writin’, and ‘rithmetic.
Don’t get me wrong. Developing specific skills is important: engineering, pre-medical training, business skills – to name just a few. But college is there primarily to expand your vision, not restrict it. More specific skills should be developed as part of a post-graduate education.
After reading the story, Jean and I reflected on our college experiences in the late 1950’s, she at William and Mary and I at LSU.
Jean was the first in her family to finish high school. For her, college was a path to world she barely knew existed. At William and Mary, she took a required core curriculum of English, History, Philosophy, Science, and Arts.
She told me of the time she first heard the words of Lewis Carroll’s “The Jabberwocky.” “’Twas brillig, and the slithy toves, Did gyre and gimble in the wabe; All mimsy were the borogoves, And the mome raths outgrabe.” She delighted in the Arts Survey Course that included architecture, visual arts, and theatre from ancient times to the 1950s. General, yes; but broadening, definitely.
Jean had discovered a new world, a world in which she lives and thrives to this day.
My experience was not as dramatic, but it was equally thrilling. I remember being absolutely stunned hearing for the first time Carl Orff’s “Carmina Burana” in my required music appreciation class, propelling me into the marvels of Twentieth Century classical music. I read some great classics in the original Greek language, absorbed absolutely great lectures on American history by one of the great historians of the day, and studied symbolic logic with a dour, but powerful Philosophy professor. I learned how to think.
This, to me, is what college should be all about – broadening horizons and discovering new worlds.
A Community Note: It’s time to nominate individuals and groups for Arlington’s annual Community Hero Awards to be given on Arlington Neighborhood Day, Saturday May 10. You are encouraged to nominate any individual or group for their “extraordinary contribution to the community.” You can access the forms on the Arlington Neighborhood website, which can be reached by going to the county website at www.co.arlington.va.us. If you have any trouble finding a form, just email me and I will send one.
Our Man In Arlington
Tom Whipple
On Monday, the Washington Post carried a provocative story about the perennial debate in the college and university community about the nature of an undergraduate curriculum.
In a nutshell, the debate is between the relative merits of a curriculum designed to provide high level skills in an increasingly professional job market as opposed a more general understanding of history and culture. As the headline put it, “Balancing Academic Tradition and Skills Employers Demand.”
I approach this debate from several perspectives: as a college student in the 1950’s, ‘60’s and now; as a college instructor in the 1960’s and now; and as a former member of George Mason University’s Board of Visitors.
My basic belief is that a college education should be principally designed to greatly expand students’ circles of knowledge; to introduce students to intellectual concepts, culture, literature, music, economic theories, theoretical mathematics and languages; and to give them the ability to articulate the knowledge they have gained. In the vernacular, it is called readin’, writin’, and ‘rithmetic.
Don’t get me wrong. Developing specific skills is important: engineering, pre-medical training, business skills – to name just a few. But college is there primarily to expand your vision, not restrict it. More specific skills should be developed as part of a post-graduate education.
After reading the story, Jean and I reflected on our college experiences in the late 1950’s, she at William and Mary and I at LSU.
Jean was the first in her family to finish high school. For her, college was a path to world she barely knew existed. At William and Mary, she took a required core curriculum of English, History, Philosophy, Science, and Arts.
She told me of the time she first heard the words of Lewis Carroll’s “The Jabberwocky.” “’Twas brillig, and the slithy toves, Did gyre and gimble in the wabe; All mimsy were the borogoves, And the mome raths outgrabe.” She delighted in the Arts Survey Course that included architecture, visual arts, and theatre from ancient times to the 1950s. General, yes; but broadening, definitely.
Jean had discovered a new world, a world in which she lives and thrives to this day.
My experience was not as dramatic, but it was equally thrilling. I remember being absolutely stunned hearing for the first time Carl Orff’s “Carmina Burana” in my required music appreciation class, propelling me into the marvels of Twentieth Century classical music. I read some great classics in the original Greek language, absorbed absolutely great lectures on American history by one of the great historians of the day, and studied symbolic logic with a dour, but powerful Philosophy professor. I learned how to think.
This, to me, is what college should be all about – broadening horizons and discovering new worlds.
A Community Note: It’s time to nominate individuals and groups for Arlington’s annual Community Hero Awards to be given on Arlington Neighborhood Day, Saturday May 10. You are encouraged to nominate any individual or group for their “extraordinary contribution to the community.” You can access the forms on the Arlington Neighborhood website, which can be reached by going to the county website at www.co.arlington.va.us. If you have any trouble finding a form, just email me and I will send one.
Recent News
Spanberger Pledges to Protect Virginians’ Fundamental Rights, Reproductive Freedoms
**DOWNLOADABLE VIDEO: Spanberger Urges Virginians to Vote to Protect Reproductive Rights This November** Spanberger: “My Opponent Has Made Clear That
CBC LWV How To Become a Candidate Forum
Running for office has always been a key facet of our democratic system of government but, in these fraught times,
Warner Unveils Latest Legislation in Push to Make Housing More Affordable for Virginians
WASHINGTON — U.S. Sen. Mark R. Warner (D-VA) has introduced two new pieces of bipartisan legislation to encourage new development, expand
Warner, Young, Colleagues Push Trump Administration to Fill Sudan Special Envoy Position as Civil War Continues
WASHINGTON – Today, U.S. Sens. Mark R. Warner (D-VA) and Todd Young (R-IN) wrote to Secretary of State Marco Rubio urging him to
Judge Giles Rejects Trump Administration Forum Shopping In Badar Khan Suri Case
Congressman Don Beyer (D-VA) today issued the following statement welcoming a ruling by Judge Patricia Tolliver Giles rejecting the Trump Administration’s attempts
Virginia Delegation Blasts Trump Administration’s Attacks On CDC Programs That Address America’s Maternal Health Crisis
Today, U.S. Senators Tim Kaine, a member of the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions (HELP) Committee, and Mark R.
Stories that may interest you
Spanberger Pledges to Protect Virginians’ Fundamental Rights, Reproductive Freedoms
**DOWNLOADABLE VIDEO: Spanberger Urges Virginians to Vote to Protect Reproductive Rights This November** Spanberger: “My Opponent Has Made Clear That She Would Put Further Restrictions On a Woman’s Access to
CBC LWV How To Become a Candidate Forum
Running for office has always been a key facet of our democratic system of government but, in these fraught times, it looms more important than ever. With this in mind
Warner Unveils Latest Legislation in Push to Make Housing More Affordable for Virginians
WASHINGTON — U.S. Sen. Mark R. Warner (D-VA) has introduced two new pieces of bipartisan legislation to encourage new development, expand supply, and make housing more affordable for Virginians. “In communities
Warner, Young, Colleagues Push Trump Administration to Fill Sudan Special Envoy Position as Civil War Continues
WASHINGTON – Today, U.S. Sens. Mark R. Warner (D-VA) and Todd Young (R-IN) wrote to Secretary of State Marco Rubio urging him to work with President Trump to appoint a new Special Envoy